Welcome to Coinfully,

A stress-free way to sell your coins for the highest price. Coinfully offers a no-pressure approach to coin dealing, with market-leading offers for your collection via a simple free appraisal. Our family-run business specializes in inherited and large coin collections and operates with complete transparency.

Your coin collection is too special not to get paid the best possible market price. When it comes to your coin collection, whether you’ve inherited one or collected it yourself, we know you want to make the best financial decision – so it’s frustrating when local offers don’t match up to what you thought your collection was worth.

As a family with a passion for coin collecting from a young age, our founders left careers in long-standing numismatic institutions to offer a ground-breaking and transparent way for the public to sell their coins. And our process always starts with us making sure you have all the facts about your collection first. We’ll help you figure out what you have in your collection and offer a free appraisal. If you want to sell and your collection’s of interest to our team, we’ll even make you a top-of-market offer that’ll have your money in the bank fast.

While we offer a concierge-style service for larger collections - where we’ll travel to you and appraise our coins in person - most of our business is done online. That helps us keep our overhead down and our offers to you much higher than you’d typically find at a coin shop.

Meet the Coinfully team:

Travis McDonald (CEO), was raised in the coin business and attended his first American Numismatic Convention in 2002. He had a storied career in the country’s premier numismatic auction house, Stack’s Bowers Galleries. Travis started off as an intern stuffing catalogs in mailing envelopes and resigned as Director of Operations after 10 years with the firm to co-found Coinfully.

Wyatt McDonald (President), continued the family legacy by working face to face with the coin collecting public in a long-standing coin shop in Charlotte, North Carolina. A student of numismatics and trained in the ANA Seminar in Denver, Wyatt is the face of Coinfully and a true expert. After spending a decade buying coins over the counter at a coin shop, he knew there had to be a better way, for everyone involved.

Deborah McDonald (Senior Advisor & Numismatist), was introduced to numismatics in 1996 by Ray Merena and Q. David Bowers and retired in 2013. During her 16 years buying and selling coins, Debbie was involved with some of the most historically significant collections ever created. Some of the most memorable were the entire Richard Eliasberg Collection, the Harry W Bass Jr. Collection and The Norweb Collection. She feels that the discovery of the 5th 1913 Nickel by Bowers and Merena was an event she will never forget. She is happy to brag about her sons being in the business with her since their early teens.

Our lifetime in the coin business has earned us the backing of famous coin collectors and numismatic authors, who, like us, could see there was a need for a better way for collectors to sell their beloved coins.

On our website you can find a bank of helpful resources to guide your numismatic journey. And if you can’t find what you’re looking for there, just reach out to our team. We’re always happy to help.